Gaming Chair or Office Chair? What to Buy for Comfort

Why this choice matters more than you think

A chair isn’t “just” a chair. If you sit for long stretches — working, studying, gaming, editing videos, trading, or doing anything screen-based — your chair becomes a piece of daily equipment that quietly shapes:

• Back and neck comfort

• Shoulder and wrist strain

• How often you fidget (a proxy for discomfort)

• Your ability to stay focused

• How tired you feel after a long session

The gaming chair vs office chair debate often gets stuck on looks, but comfort is mostly about ergonomics, adjustability, fit, and build quality — not whether the chair has racing stripes.

In this guide, you’ll learn how to choose based on your body, your desk, and your daily use, so you can buy once and sit happily for years.

What “comfort” actually means for a chair

Most people use “comfortable” to mean “feels nice for 10 minutes”. Real comfort is different — it’s what still feels fine after 2–6 hours.

Comfort usually comes from four things working together:

1. Support: especially the lower back (lumbar) and the ability to keep a neutral posture.

2. Fit: seat depth, seat height, backrest shape, armrest height/width, and head/neck support (if needed).

3. Movement: micro-movements, recline, tilt, and how easily you can change posture.

4. Pressure management: seat cushioning that distributes weight without cutting off circulation or creating hot spots.

A chair that’s “soft” but lacks support can feel great at first and awful later. A chair that’s “firm” but supportive can feel slightly unfamiliar on day one and fantastic by week two.

Quick answer: gaming chair or office chair?

Choose an office chair if you want:

• The best odds of all-day comfort (especially for work)

• Better adjustability in the mid-to-high range

• More options designed around desk posture

• A chair that generally fits professional spaces

Choose a gaming chair if you want:

• A reclined, relaxed posture for controller gaming, streaming, or casual use

• A high back with an integrated headrest look (sometimes helpful, sometimes not)

• A style-first chair and you’ve found a model that fits you well

The most accurate summary

For comfort at a desk, a good ergonomic office chair wins more often. But a good gaming chair can still be comfortable if (a) it fits you and (b) it has the right adjustments. The problem is that the average gaming chair prioritises aesthetics more than ergonomic fit.

The core difference

Office chairs are usually built for “task sitting”

That means:

• upright posture

• active typing/mouse work

• frequent small movements

• easy adjustability while seated

Gaming chairs are often built for “reclined sitting”

That means:

• leaning back more often

• relaxed torso angles

• headrest-forward designs

• style and “bucket seat” shaping inspired by car seats

Car seats are designed for a very different environment: fixed pedals, a steering wheel, vibration, and safety restraints. At a desk, that bucket shape can push your shoulders forward or limit how you sit — which isn’t automatically “bad”, but it’s not always ideal for long desk sessions.

A simple comparison table

The ergonomics baseline: what UK guidance actually expects

If you work at a screen regularly, UK workstation guidance focuses on posture and adjustability — not chair “type”. For example, Health and Safety Executive guidance highlights practical setup cues like keeping shoulders relaxed, keyboard around elbow height, seat height supporting the thighs, a small gap behind the knees, and lower-back support.

UK regulations and supporting guidance around display screen equipment also emphasise that seating should be suitable and adjustable — including seat height and backrest adjustment.

So the best chair choice is the one that helps you achieve these fundamentals consistently.

The 9 features that matter most for comfort (ranked)

1) Seat height range (and where you land in it)

A chair can be “excellent” on paper but wrong for you if the height range doesn’t match your legs and desk.

Good sign: your feet rest flat, thighs are supported, and your knees aren’t forced too high or too low.

If you’re shorter or taller than average, height range becomes a big deal.

2) Seat depth (this is comfort-critical and often ignored)

Seat depth determines whether the seat edge presses behind your knees (bad) or whether you’re perched with too little thigh support (also bad).

A common ergonomic cue is a small gap behind the knee (often quoted around a couple of centimetres).

If you share a chair (or your posture changes a lot), adjustable seat depth is one of the best features you can buy.

3) Lumbar support (integrated beats pillow for most people)

Lower-back support is the difference between “fine” and “why does my back ache every evening?”

• Gaming chairs often include a lumbar pillow. This can work, but it may shift, compress unevenly, or push too far forward.

• Office chairs more often have built-in lumbar shaping, and better ones let you adjust height and/or depth.

A pillow isn’t automatically inferior — it’s just less consistent.

4) Recline + tilt mechanism (movement is comfort)

Comfort isn’t a single posture. You want the chair to make it easy to change position:

• Synchro-tilt (back reclines while seat angle changes in a coordinated way) is excellent for desk comfort.

• Simple tilt can be fine, but might feel “tippy” or poorly balanced on cheaper chairs.

• Deep recline (common in gaming chairs) is great for breaks — but not always ideal as your default working posture.

The best chairs encourage micro-movements, not rigid stillness.

5) Armrests you can actually place correctly

Armrests should support your arms without forcing your shoulders up.

Look for:

• height adjustment (minimum)

• width adjustment if you have broad/narrow shoulders

• depth adjustment if you move close to the desk

• padded tops if you rest elbows often

If armrests prevent you from getting close to your desk, you’ll hunch forward — a comfort killer.

6) Backrest shape and shoulder freedom

Bucket-style wings on some gaming chairs can:

• push shoulders inward

• limit wide arm movement (think mouse flicks or reaching for a second monitor)

• encourage a slightly rounded upper back for some bodies

Office chairs often keep the upper back freer, which can feel better for typing and mouse work.

7) Material and breathability (comfort includes temperature)

Many gaming chairs use PU “leather” because it looks premium and is easy to wipe clean. The downside: it can run warm, especially in summer.

Mesh and breathable fabrics can feel less “luxury” but are often more comfortable for long sessions.

8) Cushion quality (too soft is not your friend)

For the seat:

• Too soft → you sink, pelvis tilts, pressure builds.

• Too firm → uncomfortable contact points.

• Just right → stable support with pressure distribution.

High-density foam tends to age better than cheap foam that quickly flattens.

9) Durability testing and standards (your hidden comfort feature)

A chair that wobbles, creaks, or develops play in the mechanism becomes uncomfortable fast.

One useful indicator is whether a chair claims compliance with commercial chair testing standards such as BIFMA (e.g., ANSI/BIFMA X5.1 for general office chairs).

You don’t need to become a standards expert — just treat reputable testing claims as a positive sign when comparing similar-looking options.

When a gaming chair can be the right buy

A gaming chair can be a smart choice when:

You play in a more reclined, relaxed way

If you mostly use a controller, watch streams, or lean back often, the deep recline and headrest style can feel great.

You need a high back and head support

Some people love a tall backrest for that “contained” feeling, especially if they take frequent reclined breaks.

You’ve tried it and it fits your shoulders and lower back

Fit matters more than category. If the wings don’t pinch your shoulders, the lumbar solution works for you, and the seat depth is right — you can be perfectly comfortable.

You’re buying a higher-quality model with real adjustments

The better gaming chairs start behaving like ergonomic chairs: stronger mechanisms, more adjustability, better foam, better armrests.

When an office chair is almost always the better buy

You work at a desk for long periods

Task-focused designs support the posture you naturally need for typing and mouse work.

You want comfort with fewer compromises

Office chairs are more likely to offer:

• adjustable seat depth

• better lumbar integration

• more breathable materials

• tilt tuned for desk work

You have back discomfort or you’re posture-sensitive

Back pain is complex and individual, but better lumbar and better adjustability tends to help you find a comfortable setup.

You want a chair that “disappears”

The best office chairs don’t constantly remind you they exist — they support you quietly while you focus.

The “hybrid user” problem (work + gaming on the same chair)

If you do both, you have three realistic strategies:

Strategy A: Buy the best ergonomic office chair you can afford

Then treat it as your all-day chair. Add comfort touches (footrest, headrest option, soft arm pads) if needed.

Best for: people who work long hours and game in shorter bursts.

Strategy B: Buy a gaming chair that behaves like an office chair

Look for:

• synchro-tilt or well-balanced tilt

• adjustable lumbar (not just a pillow)

• 4D armrests

• breathable materials

• good seat depth

Best for: people who value recline breaks and gaming aesthetics but still need desk comfort.

Strategy C: Two-chair approach (if space and budget allow)

One chair optimised for work, another for relaxed gaming. Overkill for many people, brilliant for some.

Chair fit: a quick self-check (no measurements needed)

Sit back fully in the chair and check:

1. Feet: flat on the floor (or on a footrest).

2. Knees: roughly level with hips (not forced high).

3. Seat edge: not digging into the back of the knees; you can feel a small gap.

4. Lower back: feels supported without being shoved forward.

5. Shoulders: relaxed, not raised.

6. Elbows: roughly by your sides, forearms supported comfortably.

7. Head/neck: neutral (not pushed forward by a thick head pillow).

If a chair fails two or three of these, it’s unlikely to be a long-term comfort winner.

A practical buying guide by budget

(Prices vary a lot. These tiers are about what you usually get for your money.)

Under £120: buy cautiously

At this range, the most important goal is avoid obvious ergonomic traps:

• seat too deep for you

• armrests fixed and too high

• weak tilt that feels unstable

• thin foam that compresses quickly

If you’re in this tier:

• prioritise correct seat height

• consider armless models if armrests are awful

• consider a separate lumbar cushion if needed (but don’t use it to “fix” a bad fit)

£120–£250: the “value ergonomic” zone

You can often get:

• better tilt

• better foam

• decent armrest adjustment

• mesh backs

This is where office chairs usually pull ahead for comfort-per-pound.

£250–£600: comfort becomes noticeably easier

You start seeing:

• seat depth adjustment

• better lumbar systems

• more stable mechanisms

• materials that stay comfortable longer

If you sit daily for hours, this tier often has the best ROI.

£600+: premium ergonomics and longevity

This is where high-end office chairs dominate, especially for:

• long workdays

• sensitive backs/necks

• durability over many years

If you go premium, make sure your desk setup is also good — a superb chair can’t fully compensate for a badly set-up workstation.

Don’t ignore your desk setup (it can ruin any chair)

A chair is part of a system:

• desk height

• keyboard/mouse height

• monitor position

• where you place your feet

• lighting and screen glare

Health and Safety Executive guidance includes cues like keeping shoulders relaxed, positioning keyboard around elbow height, and setting the screen so the top is around eye level and about an arm’s length away.

Also, if you use display screen equipment regularly, the UK approach emphasises assessing the whole workstation and reducing risks where found.

How to set your chair for comfort (step-by-step)

Use this as your “first setup”, then tweak over a few days.

Step 1: Set seat height

• Feet flat

• Thighs supported

• Knees not jammed up high

Step 2: Set seat depth

• Slide the seat (if adjustable) so there’s a small gap behind the knees.
  No seat-depth adjustment? You may need a small cushion behind your lower back only if it doesn’t push you too far forward.

Step 3: Set lumbar / backrest

• The curve/support should sit into the natural curve of your lower back.

• Backrest supports you when you sit back fully (not when you perch forward).

Step 4: Set recline resistance

• You should be able to lean back without fighting the chair.

• You should also not feel like you’re falling backwards.

Step 5: Set armrests

• Adjust so shoulders remain relaxed.

• If armrests force your shoulders up, lower them or remove/avoid them if possible.

Step 6: Match the chair to your desk

If your chair height makes the desk feel too high/low, consider:

• a footrest

• monitor riser

• keyboard tray

• adjustable desk (if you’re investing heavily in comfort)

Red flags: signs a chair won’t be comfortable long-term

Gaming chair red flags

• Aggressive bucket wings that pinch shoulders

• Thick head pillow pushing your head forward

• Lumbar pillow that sits too high/low and won’t stay put

• Very limited armrest adjustment

• Cheap PU that feels clammy quickly

Office chair red flags

• No back support contour at all

• Fixed armrests that hit the desk

• Seat pan too deep with no adjustability

• Wobbly base or creaky tilt right out of the box

• “Ergonomic” marketing with very few real adjustments

Special cases: what to buy if…

If you have lower back discomfort

Favour:

• integrated lumbar support (ideally adjustable)

• stable seat cushion (not too soft)

• a backrest that supports you when you sit back fully

Also: comfort improves when your workstation encourages neutral posture cues like those highlighted by Health and Safety Executive.

If you’re tall

Look for:

• tall backrest without pushing shoulders forward

• higher max seat height

• longer seat depth (or adjustable seat depth)

If you’re shorter

Look for:

• lower minimum seat height so feet reach the floor

• shorter seat depth (or adjustable seat depth)

• armrests that can drop low enough

If you run hot

Choose:

• mesh back (or full mesh)

• breathable fabric seat

• avoid cheap PU “leather” if you’re sensitive to heat build-up

If you sit extremely long hours (10–12+)

Consider “24/7” or heavy-duty chairs and pay attention to durability testing. If you’re frequently seated for long periods, a chair built and tested for sustained use can be worth it. (You’ll often see references to commercial standards such as BIFMA in this category.)

What about “ergonomic standards” like ISO?

Ergonomic guidance and standards exist, but for most buyers, the actionable takeaway is simple:

• Focus on fit + adjustability + movement.

• Use reputable guidance for posture and setup.

• Treat standards as a useful signal when comparing build quality.

For example, ISO workstation/posture guidance has evolved over time (with newer versions replacing older ones).

You don’t need to buy “ISO certified” anything to be comfortable — but it’s helpful to know that posture and workstation layout are treated seriously in established guidance.

A comfort-first shortlist: what to check before you buy

When you’re looking at product pages, reviews, or showroom testing, use this checklist:

Must-have (for most people)

• Seat height adjustment

• Backrest that supports lower back

• Stable base (5-star base, solid casters)

• Armrests that don’t force shoulders up

• A tilt/recline you can actually use

Strongly recommended

• Adjustable lumbar

• Adjustable armrests (at least height)

• Breathable materials if you run warm

• Good warranty and returns (comfort is personal)

Nice-to-have

• Adjustable seat depth

• Headrest (only if it doesn’t push head forward)

• 4D armrests (if you’re picky about positioning)

• Forward tilt (great for some desk setups)

FAQs

Are gaming chairs bad for your back?

Not automatically. Some people love them. The issue is fit and design bias: many gaming chairs use bucket shaping and pillow-based support that doesn’t suit everyone for desk work. If you can set it up well and it supports your lower back comfortably, it can be fine.

Is a mesh office chair always more comfortable?

Not always — but mesh often wins on temperature comfort and can feel supportive for long sessions. A great fabric or foam-backed chair can be equally comfortable if it fits you.

Do I need a headrest?

Only if you genuinely use it. Many people don’t need a headrest for desk work. If a headrest pushes your head forward, it can create neck discomfort. A headrest is more useful for reclined breaks than upright typing.

What’s better for posture: upright or reclined?

Neither is “the one correct posture” forever. Comfort improves when you can change posture easily. Use an upright posture for focused desk work, then recline slightly for breaks. Guidance commonly emphasises adjusting your workstation and posture to stay comfortable and supported.

How long should a good chair last?

It depends on build quality, user weight, and hours of use. Chairs with stronger mechanisms and durability testing tend to hold up better. References to commercial testing standards (like those associated with BIFMA) can be a useful sign when comparing options.

Should I buy a chair online without trying it?

You can — but treat the return policy as part of the purchase. Comfort is personal, and reviews can’t guarantee fit.

Can a cheap chair be comfortable?

Yes, especially if it fits you and your sessions are shorter. But cheaper chairs often lose comfort as foam compresses and mechanisms loosen. If you sit daily for hours, investing a bit more usually pays off.

Final recommendation: what should you buy for comfort?

If your main goal is comfort at a desk for long sessions, buy a good ergonomic office chair with:

• proper lumbar support

• adjustable armrests

• a stable tilt/recline

• seat depth that fits you (adjustable if possible)

If your main goal is relaxed, reclined gaming comfort, and you love the aesthetic, a gaming chair can work — but only if:

• the shoulders aren’t squeezed by the bucket wings

• the lumbar solution is stable and correctly placed

• it doesn’t force your head forward

The simplest rule that works for most people

• More work hours than gaming hours? Office chair.

• More reclined gaming than desk work? Gaming chair — but choose carefully.

Recommended

• 7 Clever Cool Office Desk Gadgets – STOMART.CO.UK
• Ultimate Guide to Fast-Charging USB-C Cables – STOMART.CO.UK
• Wayfair, Inc. Review: Online Furniture Shopping – STOMART.CO.UK
• Ergonomic Office Chair With Footrest – STOMART.CO.UK